Showing posts with label transfer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label transfer. Show all posts

Tuesday, 24 January 2017

LEGAL MEANING OF TRANSFER OF GOODS




The Black’s law dictionary defines transfer as the passing of a thing or of property from one person to another. It is an act of the parties or of the law by which the title to property is conveyed from one person to another.
John Bouvier's 8th edition law dictionary of 1914 defined a transfer as "the act by which the owner of a thing delivers it to another person, with the intent of passing the rights which he has in it to the latter". A mere change of possession does not amount to transfer.
Transfer is only complete when ownership changes from one person to another. While possession is a de facto relationship in which one has the physical control over a good or property, ownership is a de jure relationship that denotes one’s legal control over a good. Transfer is concerned with change of ownership.

Transfer is closely intertwined with the power of control. The question to be asked in determining transfer is, who has control over the good? The point was decided in the taxation case of Estate of Sanford v. Commissioner, 308 US 39 - Supreme Court 1939 where it was held that a gift upon trust, with power in the donor to revoke it is not taxable as a gift because the transfer is incomplete, and that the transfer whether inter vivos or at death becomes complete and taxable only when the power of control is relinquished.

Similarly, according to the court in Burnet v. Chicago Portrait Co., 285 U.S. 1, 16, 20, a transfer is only complete when "the transferor has so parted with dominion and control as to leave in him no power to cause the beneficial title to be revested in himself."
Whether a transfer has been effected and is complete is a question of control over the good. Even where a party purports to have transferred a good to the buyer, the transfer will not be complete if he holds power and control over the good. This is so especially in contracts with a Retention of Title Clause, where property in the goods only vests in the buyer upon the fulfillment of a condition such as full payment of the purchase price. In such contracts, though possession of the goods may change hands from the seller to the buyer, transfer is not complete when the condition is fulfilled and the clause becomes ineffective in the contract.
As the court observed in the case of Burnett versus Guggenheim, 288 U.S. 280, 287, the essence of a transfer is the passage of control over the economic benefits of a good rather than technical changes. The court in Corliss versus Bowers, 281 U.S. 376, 378 was of a similar view when it stated that “retention of control over the disposition of the property……………..renders the transfer incomplete until the power is relinquished……………..”

Friday, 20 January 2017

CHATTEL TRANSFER INSTRUMENT




A chattel is an item of tangible, movable character that is capable of possession. It is any movable item that is capable of delivery. When affixed to land, the chattel becomes a fixture. As was held in the case of Botham versus TSB Bank plc (1996) EG 149 whether a chattel has become a fixture will depend on;
·         The degree of annexation
·         The purpose of annexation, and
·         the permanence
A chattel instrument is an instrument creating security over a chattel. Section 2 of the Chattel Transfer Act defines a chattel instrument as any instrument given to secure the payment of money or the performance of some obligation and includes any bill of sale, mortgage, lien or any other document that transfers or purports to transfer the property in or right to the possession of chattels, whether permanently or temporarily, whether absolutely or conditionally, and whether by way of sale, security, pledge, gift, settlement or lease.
A chattel instrument should be in the prescribed form as provided in Form 4 of the First Schedule of the Chattel Transfer Act. It should state in clear terms;
1.      A description of the parties to the instrument.
2.      The date
3.      A statement showing it is an instrument meant to operate as a chattel instrument
4.      The chattel subject of the chattel security. An instrument should contain, or have endorsed thereon or attached thereto an inventory of all chattels comprised therein. The instrument does not affect any chattel contained in the schedule.
5.      Consideration
6.      Mode of payment
7.      Recognition of ownership of the chattel by the grantor
8.      Assignment of the chattel to the grantee by the grantor
9.      Covenants
10.  Execution, attestation and verification
Execution of the instrument should be attested to by at least one witness who should add his name, signature, residence and occupation. Sealing is not important for the validity of the instrument. Verification should be done by a qualified advocate. As per section 9 of the Advocates Act a qualified advocate is one who;
·         Has been admitted as an advocate
·         His name is for the time being on the roll
·         He has in force a practicing certificate. An advocate is deemed not to have a practicing certificate at any time when he is suspended from practice under section 27 of the Advocates Act.
The instrument does not take effect until it is registered. An instrument should be registered within 21days of execution by filing it and all schedules endorsed thereon, annexed thereto or referred to therein, or a true copy of the instrument and the schedules, and an affidavit in Form 1 in the First Schedule or to the same effect, in the office of the Registrar. Registration should be renewed once every five years. Failure to renew registration, the initial registration ceases to have effect upon expiration of five years since registration.
An unregistered instrument is deemed void and fraudulent as against any person seizing the chattels or any part thereof comprised in the instrument, in execution of the process of any court authorizing the seizure of the chattels of the person by whom or concerning whose chattels the instrument was made, and against every person on whose behalf the process was issued. The instrument is also void in respect of any chattels that the grantor acquires or becomes entitled to after execution of the chattel instrument.